FHA loans have been an effective way for buyers with little down payment to take advantage of the opportunity in the housing market. With low fixed rates and depressed home prices, first time buyers have who don't have a house to sell have really been in position to maximize long term gains to thier overall net worth.
The FHA tool isn't going away but it is getting ready to get more expensive. On April 1 of this year, the FHA funding fee, also known as the MIP, is increasing from the current factor of 1.0% of the loan amount to a factor of 1.75% of the loan amount. This will increase a buyers loan by .75% since the MIP is rolled into the amount financed. Also increasing on April 1 is the monthly MI. Currently at a factor of 1.15%, it will increase by 10bp to 1.25%.
To flesh this and to show the cost increase for a buyer that will result, we need to look at things as they are now. (Taxes and insurance are a constant so I have left them out of the example.):
On a $100,000 purchase price with 3.5% down payment on FHA financing, the loan amount would be $96,500 and MIP would be $965. That would be a total loan amount of $97,465. Currently the monthly MI is 1.15% factor, so $92.48/mo in this example. Using a 4% interest rate for our example this would mean a principal and interest payment of $465.31/mo + the monthly mortgage insurance of $92.48 for a total of $557.79.
After April 1, this exact same loan looks like this:
$100,000 purchase price, 3.5% down payment gives us a base loan amount of $96,500. New MIP at 1.75% is $1,688.75 for a total loan amount of $98,189. Same rate of 4% on a 30 yr fixed FHA gives us a monthly payment of $468.77. Monthly MI at a factor now of 1.25% is $100.52/mo. So principal and interest + monthly MI gives us a total payment of $569.29/mo.
$11.50/mo difference in payment. Doesn't sound like a lot but that's just a $100k purchase price home. The FHA option has been attractive for anyone buying homes as much as $275,000 (maxing out the FHA loan limit here in Columbia.) So lets look at the same example on a $250k home.
Currently: $250,000 purchase price After 4/1/12: $250,000
$241,250 base loan $241,250
$2,412.50 up front mip
$4,221.89
$243,662.50 total loan amount
$245,471.89
$1,163.28/mo principal and interest
$1,171.92/mo
$231.20/mo mortgage insurance
$251.20/mo
$1,394.48/mo payment (w/out tax/insurance)
$1,423.12/mo
$28.64/mo higher payment over just 5 years is almost $1800 out of pocket. Plus you would owe more against the home because the initial loan amount was $1808 higher. Since most first time buyers will be potential move up buyers in 5 years, these two factors alone can increase costs by about $3,700 over those first 5 years.
Does this mean don't buy? Not at all. Does this mean don't use FHA? No, not at all. What it means is that it is yet again,
that much more important that you are using an actual mortgage planner and not an application taker. This has been the focus of so much of what I have been putting out there over the last year+ and each little "tweak of the market" or change in guides only highlights this importance that much more. It means that a slightly more in depth look is going to be required to make sure that the financing you have chosen is the financing that best fits
your plans, and best fits
your goals, and not just because it was the easiest box for a loan officer to fit you in.
You are a unique individual with your own set of needs, goals, objectives, and that requires just a little more sophisticated approach than "low down payment = FHA....next..."
Set up an appointment with me via email or give me a call, we can figure out what does and doesn't make sense and this is just another reason why it's important that our conversation takes place before we start looking for a home.